Homemade Yogurt, Yes You Can!
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
Clearly from the “Yes You Can!” part of the title, I’ve watched Bob The Builder a few too many times with my kids. Nonetheless, you can make homemade yogurt! Practically anyone can, it’s that easy. So, let’s get started!
You will need: 4 cups of milk and 2 tbsp. plain yogurt (or freeze-dried culture)
1. Set the 2 tbsp. yogurt in a clean glass jar (a quart size canning jar would work great) on the counter to let it warm up a bit while you prep the milk.
2. In a pan on the stove, heat the milk to 190 degrees F (Though I’ve read 180 and 185 defrees F, but the point is to sterilize the milk, so I guess that should read: “Sterilize the milk”.) Supposedly you’re supposed to keep it from boiling by stirring it and keeping a close eye on it, but I just don’t have that kind of patience or dedication, so mine bubbles… sometimes right over the rim of the pan and onto the stove… But, hey, then I don’t have to dirty my thermometer!
3. Let the milk cool to about 110 degrees F. (You can put the pan in a cold water bath if you want to speed up the process.)
4. Stir the 4 cups of milk into the 2 tbsp. yogurt.
5. Put the lid on the jar.
6. Move to a warm place and keep the temperature between 100-110 degrees F for 6-12 hours, or until the yogurt has reached your desired consistency. (*Note: The longer it cultures, the thicker and more tart it will become.) As a good indicator, when the yogurt is “done”, you should have a pocket of whey (yellowish liquid) in the tickened white yogurt. It’s fine to eat.
7. Refrigerate your finished yogurt. (It will thicken a bit more in the fridge.)
Keeping the yogurt warm, or “incubating” it, is the most difficult part if you don’t have a yogurt maker. (I bought this yogurt maker from Amazon.com when it was on sale for $13.88, and I’ve definitely gotten my money’s worth!) A yogurt maker is just a warmer, so it’s not really a necessity. Some possibilities that may work for some people are: a cooler with warm water, a large thermos, a crockpot set on “warm” with the lid off, in your oven with just the oven light on, or in a food dehydrator. You’ll need to check the temperatures of those locations with a thermometer to make sure the temperature is correct.
You can stir fruit and/or your sweetener of choice into your finished yogurt before eating it. Just make sure to save 2 tbsp. of plain yogurt for your next batch!
Also, if you don’t have liquid milk, you can substitute reconstituted powdered milk. I usually make my yogurt out of powdered milk anyway to save money.
Let me know if I’ve forgotten anything, if you have any questions, or even if you’d just like to brag about mastering the art of yogurt making!



